A dispute over which rules apply
The proposed brief, shared Monday by Coinbase legal representative Molly Abraham, brings together Coinbase, Kalshi, Kraken parent Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm Operations. The six firms contend that existing U.S. futures law covers the contracts.
Their position challenges a lawsuit filed last week by the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA), a newly formed trade and advocacy group for traditional financial market participants. A declaration from its secretary identifies Cboe, Citadel Securities and the Healthy Markets Association among its members.
Stock perpetual futures let traders bet on changes in a company's share price without holding its stock. The absence of a fixed expiration date distinguishes them from traditional futures and is central to the legal dispute: the CMAA says they belong in the category of security-based swaps, primarily regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission and subject to stricter limits on retail trading.
The six firms counter that a security future need not have a fixed expiration date. That classification puts the products under joint CFTC and SEC oversight. They warn that a ruling for the CMAA would "send equity perpetuals back offshore," arguing that the SEC has no framework for retail trading of exchange-listed security-based swaps. They also point out that the SEC has not sought to cancel the exchanges' filings.
How the contracts reached U.S. exchanges
The approvals trace back to applications submitted Sept. 18, 2026, by KalshiEX, Coinbase Derivatives and Bitnomial Exchange. The CFTC raised no objection before its 45-day review period ended Nov. 2; under the agency's rules, that allowed the filings to take effect as approvals. On Nov. 3, the CFTC announced that U.S.-regulated exchanges could begin trading single-stock perpetual futures for the first time.
The agency treated the products as security futures under Commission Regulation 40.3 and the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000. To offer them, a venue must be a designated contract market and must also be notice-registered with the SEC as a national securities exchange for security futures products.
Kalshi started offering perpetuals tied to more than 50 U.S. stocks on Nov. 5. The complaint says its application covered 58 contracts, while Bitnomial's filing identified 10 stocks, among them Alphabet and Microsoft.
The CFTC had already faced a separate challenge over perpetual futures earlier in 2026. In June, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange sued the agency in Washington over its approval of Kalshi's bitcoin perpetual, which opened the way for crypto perpetuals on U.S.-regulated exchanges.
The alliance's two legal claims
The CMAA is challenging both the approval process and the CFTC's jurisdiction through two counts under the Administrative Procedure Act. Its first claim calls the approvals arbitrary and capricious, alleging that the agency "abruptly and inexplicably changed positions" and allowed the filings to become effective without issuing a written order.
The second claim turns on classification: the alliance says the contracts are security-based swaps that Congress placed under the SEC's authority, leaving the CFTC without power to approve them.
Trading remains allowed as the case proceeds
U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni initially found that the CMAA was likely to prevail on its argument that the CFTC had exceeded its statutory authority. In her assessment, the contracts appeared to be swaps rather than security futures.
But Caproni declined to issue a temporary restraining order because the alliance had not established imminent, irreparable harm. That left the trading approvals intact. Her Nov. 3, 2026, order dealt only with the temporary restraining order request, and her assessment of the merits has no binding effect yet, according to Ledger Insights.
U.S. District Judge Lorna G. Schofield has been assigned the case and will proceed on an expedited schedule. The CFTC's opposition to a preliminary injunction was due Friday, Nov. 6, and the CMAA's reply is due Tuesday, Nov. 10, subject to the court's discretion.












